The Cereal Killers were initially supposed to consist of Craig and Larry (who were making their return to Beerfest) and their good friend Kenny. Unfortunately, Craig and Kenny were both unable to make it, leaving Larry to pick up Beerfest alum Brendon, and rookie Brandon. They had a rough go this time only registering two 5th places in Boat Race and Beer Pong, while finishing last in the rest of the events (other than a DNF for Das Boot Relay).