The Sheep Shaggers initially consisted of Chad Chitwood, Adam, Moore, and Brian Manuz, but Brian was forced to withdraw from the competition due to an illness, replacing Brian was Nick Hackler. They finished 1st place in Turbo Quarters, had two 2nd place finishes (Ping Pong and Volume Chug), three 3rd places (Baseball Bat, Thumper, and Team Quarters), and three last place finishes (Boat Race, Beer Pong, and Flip Cup).